Our Mission
Our Market Outlook
Addressing Market Challenges
Primatics Consulting Solutions
Primatics Consulting Focus Areas
Loans/Mortage Servicing Assets
and Securitization Accounting
 
Credit Risk and Active Portfolio
Management of High Risk Loans
 
Pricing/Valuation
(Fair Value Services)
 
Compliance and Disclosures
 
Pricing/Valuation (Fair Value Services)

It is vital for a “holder” of loans / securities to understand their daily valuations for the purposes of portfolio management and financial reporting. With the industry moving towards a more fair value approach to financial reporting (e.g., with the adoption of FAS 159), the burden of controls and compliance move from accounting to an accurate, reliable and controlled way to value and price loans and securities.
 
Business
Challenges
Costs/Risks
Primatics Consulting
Methodology
Primatics Experience
Given the multitude of end users of fair value (e.g., middle office, portfolio management, accounting, regulatory), it is challenging to ensure consistent usage methodolgies to satisfy the timing and accuracy requirements of end users Inaccurate and untimely prices can have a significant impact on economic position and financial reporting Understand current state policies governing pricing methods (3rd party marks, mark-to-model, manual marks) and reference data availability

Design future state business process and architecture that best satisfies policy and end user requirements

Identify gap and implement solution around organization, data needs, technologies, and governance
Numerous middle office and pricing experience of mortgage-based loans, mortagage servicing rights, mortgage derivatives, both from a process and pure valuation perspective
Given recent re-statements and bankruptcies due to faulty valuations (e.g., residual interests), regulators and auditors are placing greater emphasis on model and pricing governance models, which can be challenging to implement and maintain in a cost effective manner Lack of controls and governance around models used for valuations can decrease management's reliance on the output, impacting key decisions and increasing overall risk Work with client to define key tenets of the governance model based on internal processes and external best practices

Design governance model, including data architecture, organizational design, and enabling technologies

Implement solution
For a large financial institution, designed and led validation of valuation output for a large MBS and structured product portfolio
Given the availability of multiple fair value sources, it is a challenge to select the right fair value provider for a given set of product(s) 3rd party model providers can miss critical product details leading to incorrect fair values

For example model providers can forget to account for prepayment penalties that have a significant impact on prices and a potential mis-statement of earnings
Define a process to validate the reliability and quality of fair values produced by 3rd party providers

From creation of internal models to hand pricing, the process has to be documented and repeatable
Defined processes around validation and also identified potential shortcomings of the pricing approach

With the introduction of
FAS 159, organizations are considering whether to adopt the standard or to retain the accrual method of accounting

There is increased risk of
model-related compliance
and version management.
Changes in model need
to be documented and
controlled resulting in
increased costs
Find the right model for the right product

Given the availability of numerous 3rd party models, it is imperative that the model supports the product completely
Validated and priced a
variety of securities and
loan products for a multi
billion dollar portfolio
 
Back | Compliance and Disclosures